Book Review – The Beardless Warriors by Richard Matheson

“How do you beat your enemy unless you fire your weapon at him? You fire and you advance–hell, that’s combat, that’s it.”

The Beardless Warriors

It’s December, 1944, and within the span of twenty days, an eighteen-year-old boy turns from green combat replacement into battle-hardened veteran. The things he sees, the actions in which he engages, forever change Private Everett Hackermeyer. The young American questions life, questions death, and questions just what the hell he’s doing mere miles outside the fictional German town of Saarbach.

It’s been awhile since I’ve read a book that chokes me up, but as I neared the end of The Beardless Warriors, it took some effort to hold back the tears. Richard Matheson, probably best known for his science fiction work (I Am Legend as well as writing for film and television), strung together the right words to cement the gravity of the material.

Young Hackermeyer joins a squad of fellow beardless warriors, each with their own distinct personalities, fears, and backgrounds. We see some fall to appendicitis and exploding mortars. We also see some make it through, though hardly unscathed. One thing is for certain: everyone is remade by the events.

The relationship between Hackermeyer and his proto-father, Sergeant Cooley, is one that will be hard to forget. Maybe it sparked thoughts of my relationship with my own father (a Vietnam veteran), or reflections of my journey into fatherhood. Whatever the reason, even as I write this review, the power of Matheson’s story still haunt me. I can only imagine experiencing what these soldiers did, and I hope that I will only have to imagine it. I’m no longer of that ripe combat age, but it does make me nervous for my son’s future.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not a pacifist and neither is Matheson, but the horrors of war are real and it may be that The Beardless Warriors is the author’s way of spreading his own experiences to those who may be privileged enough to live far from those realities. It did, after all, take him fifteen years after his own experiences to write this.

If you’re looking for a breezy read, you’ll probably want to look elsewhere. But this book was powerful. I can’t recommend it enough for those that want a page-turning, fictional experience.

Fun links to learn more:

  • My highly informal, yet somehow highly formal, book notes.
  • The Mooresville, Indiana public library actually made a book trailer for The Beardless Warriors!


0 thoughts on “Book Review – The Beardless Warriors by Richard Matheson

  1. Sounds like a great book, but I think if anyone’s due for a breezy read, it’s you. You’ve been tackling some pretty intense stuff lately!

    1. You’d think, but what’s the next thing I pick up? A Greek tragedy…. . Maybe I’ll pick up some comic books on the way home. 🙂

      1. Oh my, you’re putting the rest of us to shame.

        1. Bah, just big ambitions. They don’t always get fulfilled. 🙂

    1. Thanks Linda. Appreciate the recommendation and I’ll check out his stuff!

  2. P. S. I enjoyed your review and your notes. Wow. You are thorough. 🙂

    1. Thank you. 🙂 Part of all the effort is so I can study the plotting and characterizations. I look at it as another way to improve my writing!

  3. Great review, Phillip! I wasn’t aware of this book by Matheson. And your book notes are amazing! Do you read with a laptop or tablet by your side? Do you take notes as you read, or write them up after? I’d like to get more disciplined, you know, beyond dog-earring pages and scratching in the margins 😉

    1. I came across Matheson’s novel when searching for a “front lines” war book. I wanted to suck up some good ones as I have an idea for a similar book.

      Thanks for the compliment on the notes! What I do is heavily mark up a book as I read — summarize after each scene, underline, dog-ear, margin comments… you can definitely tell I’ve read a book when I’m done. 🙂 I don’t do this for all books, but books I really want to learn from (which is most of them). Then I go back and record everything electronically. That helps reinforce what I’ve marked and actually generates new ideas and viewpoints.

      I find that with this method, books really stick with me and I get so much more understanding out of them. My actual process is based on those of Mortimer Adler and Susan Wise Bauer. If you’d like a copy of my template, I’d be more than happy to send it to you!

      1. I’d love a copy of your template, Phillip! Thanks so much. My email address is marieannbailey[at]gmail[dot]com. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.